| An excuse I hadn’t thought of |
|
|
| Written by Dr. William M. Briggs | |
| Wednesday, 20 February 2008 | |
|
Page 2 of 3
His attempt at rebutting the skeptical criticism “The Modelers Won’t Tell Us How Confident the Models Are” furnishes us with our pseudoscientific excuse. The skeptical objection is
and Beck’s retort is
This is as lovely a non sequitur as you’re ever likely to find. I can’t help but wonder if he blushed when he wrote it; I know I did when I read it. This excuse is absolutely bullet proof. I am in awe of it. There is no possible observation that can negate it. Whatever happens is a win for its believer. If the temperature goes up, the believer can say, “Our theories predicted this.” If the temperature goes down, the believer can say, “There was no way to know the future.” |
| < Prev | Next > |
|---|








