| on Feb 27, 2008, 09:14 AM E.S.T.
|
Page 3 of 4
"The
problems we see are on the other end," Erickson said. "Will we have
enough infrastructure to transport these biofuels? Will the automobile
industry make enough flex-fuel vehicles (specially designed to run on
gas or high-ethanol blends)?"
If the goal can be achieved,
though, it will translate into major energy security gains, by
decreasing foreign oil imports, and environmental benefits, by helping
wean the nation from carbon-emitting fossil fuels, its proponents say.
That holds true for these small-scale projects as well, which will use
a variety of sources to create the fuels and are planned for
construction in Boardman, Ore.; Commerce City, Colo.; and Wisconsin
Rapids, Wis., in addition to the Missouri plant, DOE representatives
say.
"With all of these projects, the amount of fossil fuel used
to produce the biofuels is significantly less than that associated with
gasoline -- on average as much as 90 percent less over the lifecycle,"
according to a recent DOE statement.
But policymakers and
industry leaders should be cautious about investing in widespread
production before all the environmental impacts have been assessed,
said Jason Hill, co-author of a recent article, published in the
journal "Science," that questioned whether traditional ethanol
production might actually increase greenhouse gas emissions. This could
occur if land is converted to cropland to grow feedstock for renewable
fuels, the authors of the study said.
"It's a really good thing
to get these pilot facilities up and running," Hill told UPI. "The
warning is that when we scale that up to commercial size, the land use
change becomes critical."
Cellulosic ethanol -- from waste
products and high-cellulose crops -- probably won't be as harmful as
traditional ethanol, Hill said, but some, particularly energy crops,
could still require land use change.
"Where is it going to come
from?" he asked. "If it's from our fertile land, where are those crops
being displaced to? If not, it's going to come from our reserve land or
it's going to come from other land."
And all of those scenarios represent land use change.
|